Protection leveling order 13/5/33 Guide's pick, untested
Arms: Deflection 5, Improved Rend 3, Improved Charge 2, Deep Wounds 3
Fury: Cruelty 5
Protection: Shield Specialization 5, Anticipation 5, Improved Revenge 3, Improved Thunder Clap 3, Last Stand 1, Master of Defense 2, Improved Sunder Armor 3, Improved Shield Wall 1, Concussion Blow 1, Focused Rage 3, Bastion 5, Shield Slam 1
Levelling order for Protection. With the Talented legacy perk every step comes up to five levels sooner.
Protection, level 30 3/2/16 Tested in beta
Arms: Improved Rend 3
Fury: Cruelty 2
Protection: Improved Bloodrage 2, Shield Specialization 5, Improved Revenge 3, Improved Thunder Clap 3, Master of Defense 2, Vanguard 1
3/2/16 dungeon build: Shield Specialization and Master of Defense for rage, Improved Revenge and Improved Thunder Clap for threat, Vanguard to Charge in Defensive Stance. Defiance is left out because the points don't fit and the calculator doesn't include it. Concussion Blow, Focused Rage and Improved Shield Wall need 20 Protection points, so they wait for Talented or level 35. Order: the Protection levelling order, keeping this build's talents; Improved Bloodrage and Vanguard, which that order skips, go in where the tree allows.
Protection, level 60 (projected) 17/2/32 Guide's pick, untested
Arms: Improved Heroic Strike 3, Deflection 5, Improved Rend 3, Improved Charge 1, Deep Wounds 3, Impale 2
Fury: Cruelty 2
Protection: Shield Specialization 5, Anticipation 5, Improved Revenge 3, Last Stand 1, Master of Defense 2, Defiance 3, Vanguard 1, Improved Shield Wall 2, Concussion Blow 1, Focused Rage 3, Bastion 5, Shield Slam 1
"Standard" 17/2/32 tank build: Defiance, Bastion, Improved Shield Wall and Shield Slam, with Deep Wounds and Impale from Arms. Every Protection talent that matters needs a shield. Beta theorycraft; older builds with Toughness or "Vitality" are out of date. Order: the Protection levelling order, keeping this build's talents; Defiance, Vanguard, Improved Shield Wall, Improved Heroic Strike and Impale, which that order skips, go in where the tree allows.